Categories > Guides and Tips

Which is better, Manchester or Birmingham

Which is better, Manchester or Birmingham?

Ah, the age-old debate between Manchester and Birmingham – both are stellar cities in their own right, but which one nicks the top spot? Now, we won’t play favourites – we are neither a Mancunian nor a Brummie – so let’s crack on with an unbiased look, shall we?

Manchester is better to live for those seeking a vibrant cultural scene and dynamic career opportunities in the creative and tech sectors. 

However, if affordability and a relaxed lifestyle are priorities, Birmingham may be the better choice with its lower cost of living and plentiful green spaces.

So, how do we split these two urban titans? We’ll delve into the nitty-gritty of cost of living, cultural diversity, safety, and all that jazz.

Cost of Living in Manchester vs. Birmingham

From artisannutrition

Now, let’s talk about brass tacks. The cost of living can make or break your decision, and it’s a tad tricky because it’s not just about the cold, hard cash – it’s about what you get for your quid. 

Manchester and Birmingham both have their perks, but your lifestyle choices will heavily influence which city offers you more bang for your buck.

Birmingham is more affordable, with living costs approximately 10% to 15% lower than in Manchester. For instance, the average monthly rent for a one-bedroom city centre apartment in Birmingham is around £750, while in Manchester, it’s closer to £850. 

Salaries in Manchester, however, tend to be higher, with average earnings approximately 5% to 10% more than those in Birmingham, reflecting the city’s robust job market in sectors such as finance and creative industries.

Curious about the specifics? Here’s a cheeky table that compares the two cities on various expenses, from the rent you’ll fork out to the pints you’ll clink.

Expenses Manchester Cost Birmingham Cost 
Housing (Average Rent per Month) 
1-bedroom apartment  (downtown)$800$750
1-bedroom apartment (outside the city centre) $650$600
3-bedroom apartment (downtown)$1,250$1,200
3-bedroom apartment (outside the city centre)$950$900
Utilities (Average Monthly Bill) 
Utility bill for one person £130£120
Utility bill for a family £200£180
Internet plan £40£40
Transportation (Fare)
1-way ticket (local transport ticket)£2.90£2.70
Monthly pass (local transport ticket)£65£60
Taxi start (normal tariff)£3.50£3.20
Gasoline (1 litre)£1.25£1.22
Childcare (Tuition Fee)
Private Preschool/Kindergarten (full day)£800 per month £770 per month 
International Primary School £9,000 per year £8,500 per year 

And there you have it. While Manchester might have a reputation for being a tad more expensive, it also has a vibrant economy that could make those extra pounds worth it.

Birmingham isn’t lagging, though – it’s got culinary delights and cultural spots that give you a lot of bang for your buck, not to mention it’s a bit easier on the wallet for housing.

So, students and career climbers might fancy Manchester for its opportunities and social scene. In contrast, families and those after a calmer lifestyle might be tempted by Birmingham’s affordable living costs and hearty food scene.

Real Estate Prices in Manchester vs. Birmingham

From mhhgestateagents

Birmingham touts more affordable real estate prices when pitted against Manchester.

Drawing insights from the latest Real Estate Market Overview by UKHousingData.co.uk, the average price tag on a single-family home in Manchester is roughly 28.5% heftier than in Birmingham. 

As for condos, they fetch a price in Manchester that’s around 15% higher than their counterparts in Birmingham. 

The real estate market is one arena where Birmingham tends to outplay Manchester, offering a mix of both houses and condominiums at prices that don’t make your wallet weep. 

That said, Manchester counters with potentially higher property value growth, making it a tempting option for investors.

Peek at the table below to see how the average sale prices for single-family homes and condo apartments stack up between Manchester and Birmingham.

Property TypeManchesterBirmingham
Single-Family Home $320,000$250,000
Condo Apartment $220,000$190,000

Diversity and Demographics in Manchester vs. Birmingham

Manchester and Birmingham, two of Britain’s bustling metropolises, are melting pots of cultural diversity. While both cities boast a rich tapestry of inhabitants from various backgrounds, the composition of their populations offers a tapestry as colourful as a Banksy mural.

In Manchester, minorities make up a significant part of the city’s vibrancy. According to the UK Office for National Statistics, around 33% of Manchester’s population are from minority ethnic groups, contributing to the city’s dynamic urban culture and entrepreneurial spirit.

Birmingham, often hailed as one of the UK’s most diverse cities, sees an even higher percentage, with minorities constituting approximately 42% of its populace. This diversity is reflected in the city’s myriad of cultural festivals, culinary offerings, and business landscape.

Now, let’s get down to the brass tacks of geography and population. 

Birmingham is geographically larger than Manchester by 79.3%, covering an area of about 267.8 square kilometres compared to Manchester’s 115.6 square kilometres. 

However, in terms of population, Manchester has approximately 553,230 residents. Meanwhile, Birmingham boasts a larger population of around 1,141,374, which is 69.4% larger than Manchester’s.

Here’s a quick rundown of the demographic deets:

ManchesterBirmingham
Geographic LocationNorth West EnglandWest Midlands
Size (Area)115.6 square kilometres 267.8 square kilometres 
Population 553,2301,141,374
Female Population 51%51.6%
Male Population 49%48.4%
Median Age 33 years old36 years old
Life Expectancy at Birth 79 years old 78 years old 

When it comes to age, Manchester has a younger vibe, with a median age that’s a few years younger than Birmingham’s, likely due to its student population.

Now for the racial composition, which really paints the picture of diversity:

Manchester Birmingham
Population GrowthIncreased by almost 20% between 2011 to 2023.Increased by 8.0% between 2011 and 2023.
Population (2023)553,230812,000
White Population66.7% 57.9%
Asian Population17.1% 26.6%
Black Population8.6% 8.9%
Mixed Race Population4.7% 4.4%
Population Density (people/sq mile)11,650 4,200

Career Opportunities in Manchester vs. Birmingham

From bhamupdates

Data suggests that Manchester has a slightly lower unemployment rate than Birmingham. With major BBC and ITV studios based there, along with a booming tech sector, Manchester is ripe with opportunities for those in creative and digital fields. 

When it comes to career prospects in Manchester versus Birmingham, there’s much to consider. Manchester often shines as a hub for the creative and digital industries, while Birmingham boasts strengths in manufacturing and engineering.

Birmingham, while historically industrial, has diversified its economy and is now also emerging as a contender in the tech scene with the development of the Innovation Birmingham Campus and other tech hubs.

According to the UK’s Office for National Statistics, as of the latest data, the average salary in Manchester is marginally higher than in Birmingham. 

Coupled with Manchester’s cultural pull and investment in business growth, it might offer more lucrative opportunities for some professionals.

Lifestyle in Manchester vs. Birmingham

From manchester_lifestyle

Choosing between Manchester and Birmingham for lifestyle preferences comes down to what you value most in your day-to-day life. Manchester, with its reputation for music, football, and a dynamic nightlife, might be the pick for the culturally inclined and socially active.

In contrast, Birmingham, with its sprawling green spaces and more laid-back vibe, could be ideal for those seeking a balance between urban living and accessible nature.

Both Manchester and Birmingham are known for their classic British weather – marked by moderate rainfall and relatively mild temperatures throughout the year. 

Manchester is often teased for its rainy disposition, while Birmingham, being more inland, enjoys slightly less precipitation. Summers in both cities are pleasantly warm, rarely exceeding 25°C, and winters are cool, with temperatures occasionally dipping below freezing.

When it comes to activities, Manchester is a hotbed for sports enthusiasts, particularly football fans, and concert-goers, with venues like the Manchester Arena hosting international artists. It’s also a hub for the arts, with numerous galleries and the famous Manchester International Festival.

Birmingham doesn’t fall short on cultural experiences either, offering a rich array of museums, such as the Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery, and performance spaces like the Birmingham Symphony Hall. 

Moreover, it boasts the Birmingham Botanical Gardens and the proximity to the countryside for outdoor enthusiasts.

The UK’s National Health Service (NHS) covers both Manchester and Birmingham, ensuring that residents receive healthcare at no direct cost. While both cities are home to renowned hospitals and specialty health centres, Manchester’s larger size means it has more facilities. 

This includes the Manchester Royal Infirmary and the Christie NHS Foundation Trust, one of the largest cancer treatment centres in Europe.

Birmingham also provides comprehensive healthcare services with facilities like the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, which houses one of the largest organ transplant centres in Europe.

In terms of cost of living, Birmingham is generally considered more affordable than Manchester. Housing costs, particularly, are lower in Birmingham, allowing for a potentially higher quality of life for those on a budget. 

Manchester, while more expensive, counters with higher average salaries and a robust job market, particularly in creative and digital industries.

For those with families, education is a crucial factor. Both cities boast a range of high-quality educational institutions, from primary schools to prestigious universities like the University of Manchester and the University of Birmingham. 

Manchester is particularly known for its university, which is part of the prestigious Russell Group, while Birmingham offers a diverse range of educational options, including specialist schools and colleges.

Ultimately, the choice between Manchester and Birmingham for lifestyle depends on personal preferences, career pursuits, and family needs. Both cities offer a rich and varied experience, full of potential for those who seek it.

Manchester vs. Birmingham: How They Stack Up

Deciding on the ideal city between Manchester and Birmingham boils down to personal preference and what you value most in your environment. Each city has its unique charms and potential drawbacks depending on your individual needs and lifestyle choices.

To sum up our comparison, let’s take a look at which city might suit you best based on various factors we’ve discussed:

Factors The Better City Why 
Cost of Living BirminghamGenerally, the cost of living in Birmingham is lower than in Manchester, which might suit budget-conscious individuals.
Real Estate BirminghamHousing in Birmingham tends to be more affordable compared to Manchester, offering better value for those looking to purchase property.
Diversity and DemographicsManchesterManchester is renowned for its cultural diversity and youthful population, partly due to its large student community.
Career Opportunities ManchesterWith a strong presence in the creative, digital, and financial sectors, Manchester provides a wealth of job opportunities.
Crime IndexBirminghamWhile both cities are making strides in reducing crime, Birmingham may have a lower crime rate overall.
Lifestyle Tied (depends on preferences)Manchester is known for its vibrant nightlife and music scene, while Birmingham offers a more laid-back atmosphere with a mix of urban and green spaces.
HealthcareTiedBoth cities have access to the NHS with numerous reputable healthcare facilities; the choice here would depend on specific healthcare needs and proximity.

Related topics